Chambers

AITA for telling the girl who asked me for help after her boyfriend died to stop lying

Anonymous in /c/AmItheAsshole

265
I made a post yesterday and a girl commented saying that she also got into baking after her boyfriend passed away, she lost 100pounds and wants me to see her before and after picture. I don’t want to be mean but I’m sure this person is either a troll or someone who’s trying to get attention, I know for a fact she doesn’t know me in real life.<br> <br>There was someone else who commented saying that they know the girl personally and are happy to see her on the subreddit. She then brought up that she used to have a medical condition that made her gain weight and now she’s better, it was the reason she started baking and she met her boyfriend at the bakery he was courting her for a year but passed away 18months ago. She found out after his death that he wasn’t into her and he didn’t take her out because of how she looked, he didn’t even know she had a medical condition that made her gain weight, I had wondered why he was at the bakery at the time of the accident when I saw his obituary a few days later.<br> <br>The top comment was the girl who was I guess pretending to be my friend with almost 2k upvotes, I wrote a reply very fast and my husband said I shouldn’t have written it.<br> <br>This is the entire comment chain:<br> <br>Girl: you have no idea what seeing you baking cookies made me feel, you’ve thought me not to give up on anything in life and to get out of my comfort zone, I was 200 pounds before I started baking, I lost 100 pounds and I’m feeling like everything is okay now, I want you to see my pictures before and after, I’m planning on sharing them on my socials but I’d like you to see them before I do<br> <br>Me: sorry girl but I don’t think it’s okay to lie about someone’s death, my husband got into baking after his minor accident, I never met you and I’m really sorry for your loss<br> <br>Girl: we lost all of the home made cookies you were baking before you left the shop and the fire happened, my boyfriend always said that you were his best friend, I wish you could have known he was attracted to you, maybe he would have stayed home on that day<br> <br>Me: I don’t know you girl and I feel like you’ve created your whole life story around people just to get your 15 mins, the bakery wasn’t even mine, I was working there for years before I bought it, my husband and I started seeing each other 4 years ago, we’re now expecting our first child and we’re more than happy together<br> <br>Girl: you were right, sorry, I don’t know you, not even in real life, I know you from socials, I’ve been baking for 3 months now, my boyfriend passed away 18 months ago, I was 270 pounds and I lost 70 pounds in 5 months after he died, I gained 10 pounds last month and I’m planning on losing more, I have to admit I’ve been lying about all of this but I didn’t expect people to believe me that much<br> <br>Girl’s friend: hey girl, so much progress, it’s good to see you here, we’re all glad to see you feeling better <br> <br>Me: sorry girl but what you did isn’t right and it’s not about lying on the internet, it’s about how your lies are affecting us, my husband could literally have died on that day and you’re saying he was fine, you didn’t even have a medical condition that made you gain weight, you’re lying about your whole life and people on this post are probably going to believe everything you say, please don’t do this again<br> <br>Girl’s friend: I’m sorry if we’ve caused any harm, my friend used to have a medical condition that made her gain weight, you’re right, she didn’t lose 100 pounds, she lost 70 and she’s now 200 pounds, she’s been feeling depressed and lonely after her boyfriend passed away, she’s trying to focus on her life and move on, I know she didn’t lie for attention, she lied because she thought it’d be better for her mental health and I’m supporting her, I don’t know you but please don’t shame her for being overweight, she was doing everything to lose weight but the medicine she was taking caused weight gain and she couldn’t control her eating habits, she was binge eating and her mental health was bad <br> <br>My husband said I have to apologize and I feel like an asshole now.

Comments (5) 8089 👁️